With the upcoming release of Masters 25 we thought we'd take a few episodes to discuss our own picks from each set in Magics 25 year history. Here is the final part of that discussion.
Vital Statistics
Date: April 2, 2018
Appearing: Alex Steacy, Cameron Lauder, Nelson Salahub, Paul Saunders
Runtime: 01:16:54
Broadcasting live from: the Reliquary Tower on the shard of Esper on the plane of Alara.
Picks
| Set
|
Cam's Pick
|
Alex's Pick
|
Nelson's Pick
|
Honorable Mentions
|
| Shards of Alara |
Tezzeret the Seeker |
Elspeth, Knight-Errant |
Woolly Thoctar |
Sprouting Thrinax, Rhox War Monk
|
| Conflux |
Master Transmuter |
Path to Exile |
Knight of the Reliquary |
Nicol Bolas, Planeswalker
|
| Alara Reborn |
Bloodbraid Elf |
Maelstrom Pulse |
Putrid Leech |
Thopter Foundry
|
| Magic 2010 |
Doom Blade, Divination |
- |
Great Sable Stag |
Baneslayer Angel
|
| Zendikar |
Hedron Crab |
Goblin Guide |
Vampire Nighthawk |
-
|
| Worldwake |
Jace, the Mind Sculptor |
Avenger of Zendikar |
Talus Paladin |
Stoneforge Mystic
|
| Rise of the Eldrazi |
Emrakul, the Aeons Torn |
Vengevine |
Gideon Jura, Wall of Omens |
Vent Sentinel, Sphinx-Bone Wand
|
| Magic 2011 |
Sun Titan |
Inferno Titan |
- |
Steel Overseer, Primeval Titan, Destructive Force, Fauna Shaman
|
| Scars of Mirrodin |
Wurmcoil Engine |
Platinum Emperion |
Tempered Steel, Argentum Armor |
-
|
| Mirrodin Besieged |
Inkmoth Nexus |
- |
Tezzeret, Agent of Bolas |
Sword of Feast and Famine, Blightsteel Colossus
|
| New Phyrexia |
Gitaxian Probe |
Phyrexian Obliterator |
Sword of War and Peace |
Elesh Norn, Grand Cenobite, Dismember
|
| Commander |
Scavenging Ooze |
Stranglehold |
Scavenging Ooze |
Flusterstorm
|
| Magic 2012 |
Lord of the Unreal |
Adaptive Automaton |
Phantasmal Bear |
Phantasmal Image
|
| Innistrad |
Liliana of the Veil |
- |
Stromkirk Noble |
Spider Spawning, Memory's Journey, Runic Repetition, Butcher's Cleaver, Invisible Stalker
|
| Dark Ascension |
Falkenrath Aristocrat |
Lingering Souls |
Thraben Doomsayer |
Thalia, Guardian of Thraben
|
| Avacyn Restored |
Blood Artist |
Avacyn, Angel of Hope |
Wolfir Silverheart |
Silverblade Paladin
|
| Magic 2013 |
- |
- |
Thundermaw Hellkite |
Omniscience
|
| Return to Ravnica |
Goblin Electromancer |
Deathrite Shaman |
Supreme Verdict |
Abrupt Decay, Dreadbore, Sphinx's Revelation
|
| Gatecrash |
Obzedat, Ghost Council |
- |
Frontline Medic |
Boros Reckoner
|
| Dragon's Maze |
Nivix Cyclops |
Voice of Resurgence |
Ral Zarek |
Fluxcharger
|
| Magic 2014 |
Young Pyromancer |
Young Pyromancer |
Garruk Caller of Beasts |
-
|
| Theros |
Gray Merchant of Asphodel |
Polukranos, World Eater |
Whip of Erebos |
-
|
| Commander 2013 |
- |
Ophiomancer |
Baleful Strix |
True-Name Nemesis, Toxic Deluge
|
| Born of the Gods |
Courser of Kruphix |
Herald of Torment |
Brimaz, King of Oreskos |
-
|
| Journey into Nyx |
Dictate of Kruphix, Godsend |
Mana Confluence, Master of the Feast |
Eidolon of the Great Revel, Golden Hind |
-
|
| Conspiracy |
Council's Judgment |
- |
Cogwork Librarian |
Coercive Portal
|
| Magic 2015 |
Quickling |
Chasm Skulker |
Festergloom |
Triplicate Spirits
|
| Khans of Tarkir |
Morph Token |
Anafenza, the Foremost |
Mantis Rider |
-
|
| Commander 2014 |
Feldon of the Third Path |
Containment Priest |
Ob Nixilis of the Black Oath |
-
|
| Fate Reforged |
Monastery Mentor |
Soulfire Grand Master |
Gurmag Angler |
Tasigur, the Golden Fang
|
| Dragons of Tarkir |
Kolaghan's Command |
Avatar of the Resolute |
Collected Company |
-
|
| Magic Origins |
Liliana, Heretical Healer |
Hangarback Walker |
Pia and Kiran Nalaar |
-
|
| Battle for Zendikar |
Ulamog's Nullifier |
Tango Lands |
Brood Monitor |
-
|
| Commander 2015 |
Mystic Confluence |
Fiery Confluence, Meren of Clan Nel Toth |
- |
-
|
| Oath of the Gatewatch |
Thought-Knot Seer |
Kalitas, Traitor of Ghet |
- |
-
|
| Shadows over Innistrad |
Thing in the Ice |
Tireless Tracker |
Traverse the Ulvenwald |
-
|
| Eldritch Moon |
Collective Brutality |
Collective Brutality |
Emrakul, the Promised End |
-
|
| Conspiracy: Take the Crown |
Palace Jailer |
Recruiter of the Guard |
Hold the Perimeter |
-
|
| Kaladesh |
Whirler Virtuoso |
Voltaic Brawler |
Renegade Freighter |
-
|
| Commander 2016 |
- |
Ash Barrens |
Swamp |
-
|
| Aether Revolt |
Walking Ballista |
Metallic Mimic |
Tezzeret, the Schemer |
Rogue Refiner
|
| Amonkhet |
Hazoret, the Fervent, Bontu, the Glorified |
- |
Commit // Memory |
-
|
| Hour of Devastation |
The Scarab God |
Claim // Fame |
Nicol Bolas, God-Pharaoh |
Abrade
|
| Commander 2017 |
Kess, Dissident Mage |
Fractured Identity |
Leonin Stalker |
-
|
| Ixalan |
Deeproot Champion |
Legion's Landing |
Blight Keeper |
Fire Shrine Keeper
|
| Rivals of Ixalan |
Jadelight Ranger |
Dire Fleet Daredevil |
Hadana's Climb |
-
|
I 
